The Food and Drug AdministrationÂ issued its long-awaited first regulations on e-cigarettes in 2016. But controversy surrounding them hasnâ€™t exactly vanished in a puff of smoke.
The widely expected move, announced over a year ago in May 2016, requires manufacturers of so-called Electronic Nicotine Delivery Systems, or ENDS – including e-cigarettes and also vaporizers, vape pens and hookah pens – to submit their products to governmental review. The FDA also banned sales of ENDS to minors and will require product packaging and advertising to carry a warning label that the product contains nicotine, and that nicotine is an addictive chemical.
Dr. D.P. Suresh, medical director, heart and vascular at St. Elizabeth Healthcare and an outspoken critic of e-cigarettes, eagerly anticipated pending FDA regulations. â€œThis is not something that is safe,â€ he said. â€œThis is something that is very harmful.â€
E-cigarettes are battery-powered devices that give users nicotine (and other chemicals) in vapor instead of smoke; users call e-cigarette use â€œvaping.â€ There were more than 250 brands on the market in 2015, according to the National Institute on Drug Abuse, none subject to federal regulation.
â€œUse among young people has only continued to climb,â€ Dr. Suresh said.
Use of e-cigarettes increased 800 percent amongst teens between 2011 and 2014 with nearly 2.6 million high school and even middle-school students now vaping. In this same time frame, ad spending increased by 1,696 percent as marketers target teens with youth-friendly flavors like bubblegum, fruits, chocolate and latte.
Starting Aug. 8, stores will be required to check identification of buyers 25 and under, with no one under 18 allowed to buy any tobacco product, including ENDS. Also prohibited are free samples, and vending-machine sales will be limited to places where minors arenâ€™t permitted.
Absent federal regulations, there has been no way to measure what one product delivers as opposed to another. Mitch Zeller, director of the FDAâ€™s Center for Tobacco Products, has likened the unregulated industry to the â€œwild, wild West.â€
Over the next two years, any tobacco product manufactured after February 2007, which covers the overwhelming majority of the nascent ENDS industry, must submit products to FDA review of their ingredients and potential health risks.
But critics say this will be a costly burden for what has become a multi-billion dollar industry, and some wonder if itâ€™s worthwhile. A group of seven international experts, writing in the journal (si) Addiction (ei) last month, wondered if perhaps e-cigarettes were getting a bad rap as compared with their notoriously harmful tobacco counterparts.
Suresh, who as president of the board of directors of the American Heart Association, Cincinnati division, has spearheaded a local effort for more awareness and regulation, said thereâ€™s no definitive evidence linking e-cigarettes to smoking cessation, or establishing the safety of e-cigarettes.
Rawhide reports teens run a 300 percent increased risk of turning to traditional cigarettes within 12 months of smoking an e-cigarette. Extended use of e-cigarettes may lead to lung damage resulting in problems such as bronchitis and asthma and, despite popular belief otherwise, nicotine addiction.
â€œTheyâ€™re absolutely as harmful, if not worse,â€ Suresh said, citing the potential presence of additional harmful chemicals, like the carcinogen formaldehyde, in liquid and vapor. â€œThe amount of nicotine you get is just as bad, if not worse.â€